Would appreciate help with id since I'm very new to mushroom foraging.
The mushrooms were terrestrial in a predominantly mature oak forest in Massachusetts. They were found in a grassy/mossy wash area near water. Many growing in clusters and some on their own. Mushrooms are black to dark brown, funnel shaped with wavy edges that were delicate and tore easily. When cut down the center is was completely hollow until the very base where it became solid. The fertile, underside of the mushroom had pretty defined ridges with many cross-veins at the top. The top and undersides were very similar in color, with the underside being ever so slightly more grayish or lighter brownish. When cut and cleaned with a brush, the mushrooms are very fragrant and floral smelling. Spore print is white.
The well-defined ridges and all of the other characteristics in my books have me leaning towards craterellus cinereous as an identification. Possibly also craterellus foetidus. Craterellus cornucopioides and craterellus fallax, in my research, seem to be much smoother on the fertile underside than what I found. But my experience is very limited so I could be wrong. If I feel 100% confident on the id, and that they are edible of course, I intend to eat them.
Thank you!