Found these December 27, in southwestern Ohio. Predominantly hardwood forest, lots of oak, maple, and walnut. I thought they might have been Omphalotus Illudens when I saw them from a distance, but I don’t think so now.
There was no distinct odor to these, I haven’t yet tried for a spore print. I did return a few days later to see if there was any distinct color change or growth pattern, but they appeared about the same, maybe a tiny bit larger.
I’ve been going through all my guidebooks, but I’m still stumped on this one. Thanks for any help!